Raise the minimum age
Children under 14 can't understand the consequences of criminal conduct or of breaching an intervention order. The minimum age of legal responsibility in Victoria should be 14, for criminal and civil proceedings.
What’s the problem?
The current minimum age of legal responsibility in Victoria harms children. It is discriminatory, and out of step with human rights standards and medical science on child development. The UN Human Rights Council and UN Human Rights Committee have both recommended that Australia raise the minimum age of criminal responsibility to at least 14 years, in line with the Convention on the Rights of the Child, international norms and expert advice.
The minimum age should apply to civil proceedings too, including Family Violence Intervention Orders and Personal Safety Intervention Orders. The evidence and the case are the same. Children under 14 are not developmentally able to understand the consequences of criminal conduct, and nor can they understand the consequences of breaching an intervention order.
In both criminal and civil proceedings, many of these children have themselves experienced violence before they become respondents or accused. Young people are also routinely misidentified as perpetrators, with intervention orders taken out against them when their behaviour is a response to the violence and trauma they have experienced.
What action do we want?
The minimum age of criminal and civil responsibility must be 14 years, with no exceptions, in line with medical evidence and international human rights standards.
A single minimum age of 14, applied across criminal and civil proceedings, recognises that children under 14 are not developmentally able to understand the consequences of their conduct. It also stops children who have experienced violence being treated as respondents or accused. That is the standard set by medical evidence and international human rights bodies.
Raising the age must not come with strings attached. Any laws which lower the age of criminal responsibility must not include new police powers which expose children under 14 to unnecessary police contact, risk re-criminalisation or undermine the intent of these reforms. Children who need support should receive it through health, education and community services, not through courts and police.
We're an independent, not-for-profit legal service.
Our advocacy is shaped by what we see young people go through, not by who funds us or which government is in power. When we take a position, it's ours.
Latest Media Releases
Youthlaw has today given evidence to the Victorian Government’s Inquiry into Public School Funding, warning that the decision to delay raising public school…
The Justice Legislation Amendment (Family Violence, Stalking and Other Matters) Bill, also known as the Women’s Safety Package, recently passed in Victoria…
The Victorian Government’s ‘adult time for violent crime’ youth justice sentencing reforms tabled today ignore warnings from legal experts and clear evidence…
Youthlaw has condemned the Victorian Government’s proposed overhaul of the youth justice system, describing it as rushed, punitive, and dangerously out of…