End prison for unpaid fines
No young person should be locked in prison because they can't afford to pay their fines. We want imprisonment ended as a punishment for unpaid fines, because fines should not punish poverty.
What's the problem?
Fines hit young people hardest, because they are more likely to be on low or no income and less likely to know their options for dealing with a fine early. Many of the young people who receive fines are already experiencing homelessness, family violence, mental health issues or disability.
When they can't pay, enforcement costs pile up and small fines quickly turn into debts of thousands of dollars. Rather than changing behaviour, fines punish young people for poverty and disadvantage, trapping them in debt and stress that can follow them into adulthood.
The threat of imprisonment does enormous harm. Fear of being locked up pushes young people into desperate choices to make the fines go away, like handing over their Centrelink payments, taking out credit cards or dodgy loans, borrowing money they can’t afford to repay, or going without food, rent or medication. These choices push young people further into hardship.
What action do we want?
End imprisonment as a punishment for unpaid fines, so that no young person is jailed because they can't afford to pay.
The amount of money in your bank account shouldn't determine whether you can continue to live in the community, or face imprisonment. Young people on low or no income should be able to resolve a fine without fearing prison.
The threat also stops young people from seeking help. Many are too scared or anxious to engage with the fines system, so they miss out on options like withdrawal of fines for special circumstances, Work and Development Permits or affordable payment plans that could have resolved their fines without pushing them into crisis.
As long as imprisonment remains on the table, the fines system will keep trapping young people in poverty instead of helping them move forward.
We're an independent, not-for-profit legal service.
Our advocacy is shaped by what we see young people go through, not by who funds us or which government is in power. When we take a position, it's ours.
- Court & criminal charges
Fund early intervention
Early legal and social work support keeps young people out of the criminal legal system.
- Court & criminal charges
Bail and remand reform
We want the 2025 bail reforms reversed and Poccum's Law implemented in full, to keep children safe in the community.
- Court & criminal charges
A specialist Young Adult List
A Magistrates' Court list with trained magistrates and links to supports, like the New Zealand model, to promote diversion and rehabilitation.
Latest Media Releases
New exclusion laws could ban young people from…
Youthlaw, Victoria’s specialist legal service for young people, says…
Youthlaw rejects calls for harsh and ineffective…
Every young person in Victoria deserves the chance to turn their…
“This is not just a NSW problem”: Victorian…
Victoria’s youth legal service says Monday night’s Four Corners…